बुधवार
Subscribe
REEL34
SCENEBollywood
TAKE18.11.26
RUNTIME3 min read

HJS urges Hindus to skip Ramayana, seeks part 2 screening

Hindu Janajagruti Samiti has asked Hindus not to watch Nitesh Tiwari's Ramayana: Rise of a Legend and wants a special screening of part two before release.

HJS urges Hindus to skip Ramayana, wants part 2 screening

The conversation around Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana: Rise of a Legend has shifted from box office chatter to faith. The Hindu Janajagruti Samiti (HJS) has asked Hindus not to watch the newly released film, claiming it distorts Maharshi Valmiki’s epic and presents Lord Ram, Sita, Lakshman and Ravana in ways that hurt religious sentiments.

HJS Goa coordinator Manoj Solanki aired the objections in a statement on Tuesday evening, and the group held a press conference in Mumbai the same day. The organisation called the film an attempt to push what it described as a “Communist agenda” through modern ideological readings of the epic.

What HJS says the film gets wrong

The complaints are scene-specific, not a general dismissal. According to HJS, the most contentious choices include:

  • Ravana: shown as a ruler who shields the oppressed and gives gold houses to the poor, turning the demon king into a symbol of social justice.
  • Shurpanakha: shown approaching Ram with a marriage proposal before Lakshman cuts off her nose; Sita then rebukes Lakshman and Ram apologises to Khara and Dushana.
  • Lakshman: shown as arrogant, quick-tempered and sarcastic with Ram and sages such as Vishwamitra and Agastya, instead of humble and devoted.
  • Ram and Lakshman in battle: shown falling back against Khara, Dushana, their demon army and Tataka, which HJS says undercuts their traditional image as fearless warriors.
  • Sita: shown fighting demons earlier but offering no resistance during her abduction; HJS also questions Ravana’s absence from the swayamvar sequence.

Solanki said these additions do not exist in the Valmiki Ramayana and asked why Hindu sentiments had not been given the same consideration as objections raised to films such as Messenger of God, The Da Vinci Code and a scene in Kamaal Dhamaal Malamaal.

The CBFC is now part of the debate

HJS has also accused the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) of not properly scrutinising the film’s religious aspects. The group’s demand is systematic: the board should study scriptures and consult scholars before clearing any film based on a religious epic, so original narratives are not distorted.

That call pushes the dispute beyond one film. In a country where mytho-fiction regularly becomes a box office event, pre-release consultation with community leaders could become a standard check if enough voices support it.

What comes next

The immediate demand is a special screening of the second part for Hindu religious leaders, seers and Ramayana scholars before its release. Solanki also urged the government to take note of what the group calls denigration of Lord Ram. He left no ambiguity about the group’s next step:

“If similar distortions are found in the second part, we will take to the streets across the country and strongly oppose the film,” Solanki said.

For fans who are still deciding whether to watch, the objection list is specific enough to evaluate on its own terms. Whether you read the film as adaptation, interpretation or distortion, the next few weeks will show whether the makers respond, and whether part 2’s release plan changes.

Source: The Times of India

Comments आपकी राय

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Friday's box office, in your inbox by Saturday.