2 Telugu films, 4 industries: Janhvi’s South row
Janhvi Kapoor's Koffee with Karan remark that South films rarely have bound scripts drew backlash after she had worked in only two Telugu films.

Janhvi Kapoor’s Koffee with Karan Season 9 appearance was supposed to close the chapter on Peddi. Instead, one line about how films are shot in South India has opened a bigger argument about who gets to describe a whole cinema culture.
Janhvi was reacting to the backlash around her character Achiyamma in Ram Charan’s Telugu sports drama. She said she had spent time blaming herself for not being more vigilant and admitted she should have used her privilege. She also described parts of the shoot as “a violating experience in a way.” But the sentence that travelled fastest was about production: “In the south, very rarely there is a bound script. Very rarely do you see the camera angles.”
Why the statement drew quick criticism
Social media users pointed out that Janhvi has worked in two Telugu films so far. That is a slim sample from which to make a claim about Tamil, Telugu, Kannada and Malayalam cinema, four industries with their own production rhythms, budgets and working methods.
The strongest objection was not about whether she felt uncomfortable on Peddi; it was about scaling that experience into a regional rule.
- Two Telugu films became the basis for a statement about four industries.
- Tamil, Telugu, Kannada and Malayalam cinema do not share one production method.
- Script and camera planning vary from project to project, even within a single industry.
- Peddi director Buchi Babu Sana had already apologised and removed the contested scenes.
The Peddi timeline
Peddi drew criticism for how Achiyamma was framed, with viewers pointing to lingering waist and navel close-ups and a romantic track that some read as harassment being repackaged as romance. Buchi Babu Sana later said he had not anticipated the negative reading, apologised, and promised the team would be more careful with its portrayal of women. The contested shots were removed, and an extended cut announced for June 17 restored three scenes while leaving the objectionable portions out.
Why the language matters
Calling something “South cinema” is convenient shorthand, but it hides more than it reveals. A Malayalam film with a tight schedule and an independently driven script does not work like a big Telugu action drama, and a bound script is a production choice, not a permanent cultural trait.
For actors and viewers, the more useful habit is to go project by project. Ask what is locked before filming, who controls the final edit, and what the on-set protocol is for raising discomfort. The lesson in Janhvi’s admission is not that she was wrong to speak; it is that specificity would have protected her point. The row underlines how protective audiences are of their industries, and how quickly a broad phrase can read as blame-shifting.
What to take away
- Ask for a locked script and shot list before signing, whatever the language.
- Raise discomfort early and in writing, not only after release.
- Judge a production by its director and process, not by a region-wide label.
Janhvi’s conversation has already pushed one useful question into the open: when an actor speaks about a bad set, should they name the film or the system? The answer is not always clean, but the distinction is the whole debate.
Source: India Today




Comments आपकी राय